4D-Lipidomics™ workflow for increased throughput
- Florian Zubeil 1
- Aiko Barsch 1
- Sven W. Meyer 1
- Heino M. Heyman 1
- Ansgar Korf 1
- 1 - Bruker Daltonics GmbH & Co. KG
Aug 23, 2021
Lipid profiling from complex lipid extracts can be a challenging and time consuming task. The high complexity of samples and co-elution of isobaric or isomeric compounds complicate the confident annotation of lipids. The presented 4D-Lipidomics workflow simplifies and streamlines the annotation and validation process using mobility-enhanced MS data.
Lipids represent an important compound class in biological systems as they play key roles in cell membranes, in the energy storage or as signaling molecules. This makes them interesting markers for studying biological systems regarding clinical research . At the same time, lipids depict a highly complex class of compounds. Both, the structural diversity as well as the high dynamic range in concentrations makes the analysis of lipid extracts challenging. A major bottleneck in lipid profiling is the annotation and subsequent validation of lipid assignments. Additionally, a high throughput is often necessary, e.g. in phenomics related large cohort studies.
Using the timsTOF Pro or timsTOF fleX systems, a high MS/MS coverage can be achieved by the PASEF®  acquisition mode, even with single in-jections and when using fast LC gradients. Furthermore, the trapped ion mobility separation cleans up the MS/MS spectra and improves the matching of fragmentation rules or spectral libraries. As a third factor of improvement, the automatically acquired CCS values can be directly used to increase the confidence in annotations. This 4D-Lipidomics workflow is demonstrated in detail in the following.
Lipids from NIST SRM 1950 reference plasma (Sigma-Aldrich, Germany) were extracted using methyl-tert-butyl ether (MTBE) based on a protocol published by Matyash et al. . Extracts were dissolved in Methanol : Dichloromethane (9:1). The total amount of lipids injected on column equaled 0.5 μL and 5 μL extracted standard for positive and negative polarity, respectively. To assess the reproducibility of the system, 5 replicates were analyzed in each polarity (5 μL each).
The RP-LC separation was performed using an Elute UHPLC system (Bruker, Germany) and a Triart C18 column (100 x 2.1 mm, 1.9 μm) (YMC, Japan). Run times were 5, 10 and 20 minutes, respectively. The MS- and MS/MS data was acquired in positive and negative ESI mode using a timsTOF Pro (Bruker Daltonik, Germany) instrument in PASEF MS/MS mode. The transfer parameters were optimized for 100-1500 m/z.
The resulting four-dimensional data (m/z, RT, mobility, and intensity) was processed using MetaboScape® 2021b (Bruker, Germany). The T-ReX® 4D algorithm combined common adducts and isotopes belonging to the same compound into features in the bucket or feature table. Features detected in less than three of five samples were discarded. Furthermore, features with a Coefficient of Variance (CV) of >20% were excluded. The remaining features were annotated using a rule-based annotation tool in MetaboScape 2021b. It makes use of published fragmentation rules for >40 lipid sub-classes and it annotates based on the precursor m/z, isotopic pattern, and characteristic fragments in the MS/MS spectra. To compare the number of unique lipid annotations on species level, only the most abundant species of isomers were considered. All isomers eluting with different retention times were removed.
Data of positive and negative ionization was processed separately and merged based on retention time and neutral mass in MetaboScape.
The aim of this study was to investigate the benefits of the timsTOF Pro /fleX-based 4D-Lipidomics worflow to profile the lipid content of a SRM 1950 extract. The scheme of the workflow is outlined in Figure 1. Each step will be discussed in more detail in the following.
The timsTOF Pro and timsTOF fleX instruments are trapped ion mobility-enhanced QTOF mass spectrometers that provide an advanced acquisition mode (PASEF) for high-speed and high-quality MS/MS data [2,4,5]. Since confident lipid identification is dependent on high-quality fragment spectra, both a comprehensive coverage as well as sensitivity are of key importance for downstream analysis. In addition to generating cleaner MS/MS spectra, the trapped ion mobility separation automatically acquires accurate and precise CCS values that can be directly used in CCS-aware processing softwares to increase the quality and hence also the user’s confidence in results.
The coverage of MS/MS spectra acquired with PASEF is shown in Figure 2. Multiple replicate injections are not required to improve the precursor fragment coverage but were acquired to assess the Coefficient of Variance (CV) for filtering reproducible ions. This is not necessary if biological replicates are available.
MetaboScape 2021b is a server-client based software allowing multiple users to process and evaluate their data at the same time. It enables processing of 4D-timsTOF data as well as MALDI-TIMS-Imaging data, high-end MRMS data or standard QTOF data. The central processing algorithm, T-ReX (Time aligned Region complete eXtraction) extracts all relevant feature information and creates a retention time aligned 4D compound or feature table. Automatically applied charge deconvolution, deisotoping and recursive feature extraction grant robust results as a basis for subsequent statistical experiments, dereplication or de-novo annotation workflows that are also implemented in the software solution. Figure 3 shows a screenshot of a compound table with example annotations from the presented data.
CCS-aware lipid annotation
To annotate lipids, MetaboScape offers two complementary workflows that can be used independently from each other. The rule-based lipid annotation is fully implemented in MetaboScape 2021b and aims at providing high-quality, confident lipid annotations according to the latest developments in the lipidomics community . It features fragmentation rules for a wide range (> 40) of common lipid sub classes. By applying rule-based annotation, over-annotation of lipids can be avoided which can occur when matching lipid spectra against MS/MS libraries. An example of how the rule-based annotation is applied is illustrated in Figure 4 for the lipid PC 22:6_16:0.
Alternatively or additionally, the CCS containing open-source MS/MS library LipidBlast can be used. It was compiled by Tsugawa and Fiehn et al.  and contains > 1/2 million of CCS values for lipids, together with their in-silico generated MS/MS spectra. The CCS values of the library were predicted based on CCS values acquired on a timsTOF Pro instrument.
Imported into MetaboScape, the library can directly be used to annotate the feature table. This complementary annotation can increase the coverage of lipid classes. Additionally, it enables to gain a higher confidence in the results by confirming previous annotations and matching MS/MS spectra as well as CCS values. Figure 5 shows an example of the data.
Both annotation strategies use the Annotation Quality Scoring (AQ column in Figures 4 and 5) to give a visual feedback on the key qualifiers (rt, m/z, isotopic pattern, MS/MS matching, CCS for LipidBlast). The ranges for this rating are user-defined.
In addition, the acquired CCS values can be used to verify potential lipid structures by comparison with predicted values. This is possible in MetaboScape using an implemented tool called CCSPredict. The CCS values for several adducts can be compared to increase the user’s confidence in the automatic annotations.
Deep analysis of annotation results
To simplify the process of validation of the annotations, MetaboScape features a 4-dimensional Kendrick mass defect (KMD) plot that enables a deep analysis of the annotation results . Annotated lipids can be validated and outliers (possible false positives) as well as missing lipids (possible false negatives) can be readily identified. In Figure 6, a KMD plot for the PC lipid class is shown, demonstrating the power of this plot to validate annotations based on trend lines that can be observed for the homologous series.
Highly confident lipid annotations based on CCS-aware results
To investigate the increased MS/MS quality and peak capacity provided by PASEF, we analyzed a lipid extract of NIST SRM 1950 reference plasma with different chromatographic run times of 20, 10 and 5 minutes. As shown in Figure 7a, the maximum number of unique identified lipids (362) was observed with 20 min gradient times. Even when reducing the runtime to 25% (5 min), still 75% (271) of the annotated lipids with a CV of less than 20% where detected.
A comparison of the measured CCS values from the 20 min and 5 min gradients shows a very good correlation (Figure 7b). This demonstrates that in contrast to retention times, CCS values are independent of chromatography and can be reliably used for compound identification (Figure 7C). The results highlight the exceptional usefulness of CCS values for compound identification. Different gas conditions during the ionization of compounds did not influence the collisional cross sections acquired in TIMS. These results set the stage for deep lipidomics profiling at high throughput to enable studies that require a high turnover, for example clinical research studies.
In addition, the 4D-Lipidomics workflow can be leveraged by using the annotated compounds in combination with MALDI Imaging experiments. The so-called SpatialOMx® workflow matches accurate mass and CCS values to correlate the annotations to MALDI Imaging experiments. This enables to assess e.g. the spatial distribution of identified lipids in tissue [9,10].
The presented 4D-Lipidomics workflow features highly confident CCS-aware lipid annotation by state-of-the-art rule-based annotation. It simplifies the inspection of the annotations by 4D Kendrick Mass Defect plots. The timsTOF Pro or fleX instruments build the basis of this workflow delivering high-quality data at short runtimes.
- PASEF enables high throughput lipid profiling.
- The 4D-Lipidomics workflow ensures a confident annotation of a wide range of lipids, even from single injections.
- The lipid annotation tool in MetaboScape provides rule-based annotation for >40 sub-classes and reports according to most recent guidelines.
- Increasing the chromatographic speed four-fold, the presented workflow still yielded 75% of the maximum annotations observed. This underlines the suitability for high-throughput studies.
- By matching the CCS values and accurate m/z of annotated lipids, the spatial distribution e.g. in tissue can be assessed by MALDI Imaging data using the SpatialOMx workflow.
 Züllig et al. (2020), Mass Spectrom. Rev., early view, https://doi.org/10.1002/mas.21627
 Mann et al. (2018), Mol Cell Proteomics, 17(12):2534-2545. doi: 10.1074/mcp.TIR118.000900. Epub 2018 Nov 1.
 Matyash, V. et al., J. Lipid Res., 49, 1137-1146 (2008)
 Application Note LCMS-158, Using Parallel Accumulation Serial Fragmentation (PASEF) to speed up untargeted 4D lipidomics LC-MS/MS workflows.
 Application Note LCMS-175, Investigating the increased lifespan in C. elegans daf-2 mutants by 4D-Lipidomics.
 Liebisch et al., The Journal of Lipid Research, 61, 1539-1555.
 Tsugawa et al. (2020), Nature Biotechnology, 38, 1159–1163.
 Hayen et al. (2018), Rapid communications in mass spectrometry, 32, 981-991. https://doi.org/10.1002/rcm.8117
 Hayen et al. (2021), Anal. Chem., 93, 4, 2135–2143. https://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/acs.analchem.0c03942
 Helmer et al. (2021), Analytical Chemistry.